Disclosure: OnlyVPNGuide.com may earn a commission if you purchase through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our editorial conclusions. Read our full Affiliate Disclosure.
Quick Answer
Surfshark wins overall for mainstream usability and streaming-friendly value, while Private Internet Access remains the stronger specialist choice for port forwarding and highly configurable P2P use. Both services are credible VPN options, but they target different priorities. Private Internet Access is currently positioned around torrenting, port forwarding, customization, unlimited devices, and low long-term cost, while Surfshark is positioned around budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value. This is a draft comparison tied to the current OnlyVPNGuide review records, so every changing fact should be rechecked before publication.
Compare at a glance
Plan details below come from the linked VPN reviews. Missing or unverified fields are labelled; no speed benchmark is implied.
| Feature | Private Internet Access | Surfshark |
|---|---|---|
| Price / plan | $1.79/month on the current 3-year promotional offer | $2.49/month for the current Starter 24-month offer with extra months |
| Server information | Not independently verified by OnlyVPNGuide | 4,500+ |
| Countries / locations | 91 | 100 |
| Simultaneous connections | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Logging policy | Strict no-logs policy; PIA says it stores no browsing, IP, DNS, timestamp, or bandwidth logs | Audited no-logs policy; Surfshark says it does not track or store browsing activity |
| Jurisdiction | United States | Netherlands |
| Refund terms | 30 days for new subscribers under current terms | 30 days for eligible first purchases |
| Best suited to | Torrenting, port forwarding, customization, unlimited devices, and low long-term cost | Budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value |
| Full review | Read Private Internet Access review | Read Surfshark review |
Prices, locations and refund rules can change. Confirm the full payment, renewal and eligibility terms on the provider’s website before purchasing.
Key Takeaways
- Overall winner: Surfshark.
- Private Internet Access best fit: Torrenting, port forwarding, customization, unlimited devices, and low long-term cost.
- Surfshark best fit: Budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value.
- Current price reference — Private Internet Access: $1.79/month on the current 3-year promotional offer.
- Current price reference — Surfshark: $2.49/month for the current Starter 24-month offer with extra months.
- Connections — Private Internet Access: Unlimited; Surfshark: Unlimited.
- Use the master VPN Reviews as the source of truth for facts and affiliate URLs.
Key Differences
The biggest difference between Private Internet Access and Surfshark is not one headline statistic. It is the type of user each product serves best. Private Internet Access's current review emphasizes torrenting, port forwarding, customization, unlimited devices, and low long-term cost, while Surfshark's emphasizes budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value. That distinction matters more than unqualified claims about being the fastest or most secure VPN.
The comparison table above is linked to the master VPN Review records. Current price, server footprint, country coverage, simultaneous connections, logging summary, jurisdiction, refund period, best-for label, and affiliate destination are therefore maintained in one place. This article should concentrate on interpretation: which differences matter in daily use, where one provider has a practical advantage, and who should choose the alternative.
Speed Comparison
We have not assigned a new OnlyVPNGuide laboratory speed winner for this comparison. The current master review fields show Private Internet Access's speed entry as 'Not independently verified by OnlyVPNGuide' and Surfshark's as 'Not independently verified by OnlyVPNGuide'. If either field contains Not independently verified by OnlyVPNGuide, keep it unresolved until both VPNs are tested using the same methodology.
For a fair head-to-head test, use the same device, ISP connection, time window, baseline speed, protocol class, and server locations. Test a nearby server and multiple long-distance regions, then record download speed, upload speed, latency, connection time, and stability across repeated runs. A one-off test is not enough to declare a permanent winner because VPN performance changes with distance, congestion, routing, protocol choice, and local network quality. If one provider wins your final test, report the measured difference and exact method.
Privacy & Security
Private Internet Access's current logging summary is: Strict no-logs policy; PIA says it stores no browsing, IP, DNS, timestamp, or bandwidth logs. Its listed jurisdiction is United States. Surfshark's current logging summary is: Audited no-logs policy; Surfshark says it does not track or store browsing activity. Its listed jurisdiction is Netherlands. Jurisdiction matters, but it should not be treated as a complete privacy score by itself.
A stronger comparison checks what activity and connection data each provider stores, whether its no-logs claims have been independently audited, what account and payment data remain, which protocols are available, and whether the apps include a dependable kill switch and leak protection. Review both current privacy policies and the latest audit scope before publication. Where there is a past incident or legal test relevant to logging, explain it with dates and context rather than using it as a permanent marketing label.
Streaming Comparison
Streaming access changes because platforms continually update VPN detection. The current Private Internet Access review positions the service around torrenting, port forwarding, customization, unlimited devices, and low long-term cost, while the Surfshark review emphasizes budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value. Those strengths indicate which service is worth testing first, but they do not guarantee any particular streaming library.
Test both VPNs against the same services, regions, and devices. Record whether playback starts, the resolution reached, buffering, how many server changes were required, and whether Smart DNS or a TV app is involved. If one VPN works more reliably in the final test, date that result. Avoid promising permanent access because a streaming provider can change its blocking behavior after your review is published.
Torrenting / P2P
For P2P use, the important questions are whether torrent traffic is permitted, whether port forwarding exists, whether the kill switch blocks traffic during a forced drop, and whether DNS or IP leaks appear under load. The current Private Internet Access review notes: PIA is one of the strongest P2P-focused VPNs because it supports port forwarding in eligible locations, allows P2P traffic, offers unlimited bandwidth, and provides a kill switch. Current independent testing ranks it extremely highly for file sharing. A reliable P2P review should check more than whether BitTorrent launches. Confirm which servers permit P2P, whether the provider offers port forwarding, whether the kill switch remains active during a forced disconnect, and whether DNS/IP leaks app. The current Surfshark review notes: P2P traffic is supported and the service provides fast modern protocols, but it does not offer port forwarding. Users who need inbound port mapping for P2P workflows may prefer PIA, Proton VPN, or hide.me. A reliable P2P review should check more than whether BitTorrent launches. Confirm which servers permit P2P, whether the provider offers port forwarding, whether the kill switch remains active during a forced disconnect, and whether DNS/IP leaks appear while the client is under load. We have no.
Do not judge torrenting only by peak download speed. Port forwarding and granular network controls can be more useful to a serious P2P user than a small speed advantage. Conversely, a user who never needs inbound connections may value simpler apps, broader streaming support, or an easier multi-device setup. VPN use does not change the legality of the content involved.
Apps & Ease of Use
Private Internet Access currently allows Unlimited simultaneous connections, while Surfshark allows Unlimited. Connection count matters for households, but app quality depends on more than the number of devices. Compare Windows, macOS, Android, iOS, Linux, routers, browsers, and TV apps separately because features can vary by platform.
During hands-on testing, check installation, login, server search, fastest-server selection, protocol switching, split tunneling, kill-switch behavior, reconnect behavior after sleep, and whether important privacy controls are enabled by default. The better app is not automatically the one with the most switches; it is the one that makes safe behavior clear while still giving experienced users the settings they need.
Server Network
The linked reviews list Private Internet Access with 18,651 (current third-party index) servers and 91 countries/locations. Surfshark is listed with 4,500+ servers and 100 countries/locations. Treat these as dated snapshots rather than permanent totals.
Raw server count is not a quality score. Providers count physical servers, virtual instances, cities, and locations differently. Capacity, routing, geographic placement, nearby city options, RAM-only design, and server ownership can matter more than the headline total. Verify both live server pages before publication and note virtual locations where they are disclosed.
Pricing & Value
Private Internet Access's current price reference is $1.79/month on the current 3-year promotional offer; Surfshark's is $2.49/month for the current Starter 24-month offer with extra months. These are promotional snapshots. The refund references are Private Internet Access: 30 days for new subscribers under current terms; Surfshark: 30 days for eligible first purchases.
Compare total upfront cost, term length, extra months, taxes, automatic renewal terms, renewal pricing, refund exclusions, and which features require a higher plan. A low advertised monthly equivalent can require a long commitment. A more expensive VPN can still be better value when its specific privacy, streaming, or networking features match the buyer's needs. Check both checkout pages on the day the article is updated.
Customer Support
Support matters most when something breaks: a streaming service stops working, a router configuration fails, a refund is needed, or a network blocks VPN traffic. The full reviews summarize current support options, but a fair comparison should contact both providers with the same realistic technical question and record response time, accuracy, and whether a human actually resolves the issue.
Also compare self-service documentation. A detailed, current knowledge base can be more useful than fast chat for advanced setup. If one provider offers 24/7 live chat while the other relies more on email or documentation, explain who benefits from that difference.
Who Should Choose Private Internet Access
Choose Private Internet Access if your priorities match Torrenting, port forwarding, customization, unlimited devices, and low long-term cost. It is especially worth shortlisting when the device policy, pricing structure, privacy design, streaming performance, or specialist features in the full Private Internet Access review solve a problem you actually have. Read the complete review before buying because this comparison intentionally summarizes rather than repeating every limitation.
Who Should Choose Surfshark
Choose Surfshark if your priorities are closer to Budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value. Focus on the differences that materially affect you, such as unlimited devices, privacy design, P2P tools, streaming convenience, app simplicity, or price. The complete Surfshark review should be your final fact-check source before purchasing.
Final Verdict
Surfshark wins overall for mainstream usability and streaming-friendly value, while Private Internet Access remains the stronger specialist choice for port forwarding and highly configurable P2P use. That is the recommendation for a typical buyer, not a universal rule. The better VPN depends on whether your main goal is streaming, privacy, P2P, travel, price, or covering many devices.
If you are still undecided, use the live facts table at the top and then read both linked VPN reviews. The table pulls its core data and affiliate destinations from the review records, which makes the comparison easier to maintain as provider facts change. before purchasing, resolve every Not independently verified by OnlyVPNGuide field, confirm pricing and refund terms, and run the same hands-on test workflow on both services.
FAQs
Which is better overall, Private Internet Access or Surfshark?
For most users in this comparison, Surfshark is the overall winner. Surfshark wins overall for mainstream usability and streaming-friendly value, while Private Internet Access remains the stronger specialist choice for port forwarding and highly configurable P2P use. The better choice can change if your priority is a specialist feature such as port forwarding, anonymous signup, unlimited devices, or a specific streaming platform.
Which is cheaper, Private Internet Access or Surfshark?
The current price references are Private Internet Access: $1.79/month on the current 3-year promotional offer; Surfshark: $2.49/month for the current Starter 24-month offer with extra months. Promotional pricing and renewals change, so compare the live checkout total and renewal terms rather than relying only on the advertised effective monthly rate.
Which is better for privacy, Private Internet Access or Surfshark?
Privacy depends on more than jurisdiction. Private Internet Access currently states strict no-logs policy; pia says it stores no browsing, ip, dns, timestamp, or bandwidth logs, while Surfshark states audited no-logs policy; surfshark says it does not track or store browsing activity. Compare their latest audit scope, account data, protocols, kill switch, leak protection, and legal history before declaring a privacy winner.
Which is better for streaming, Private Internet Access or Surfshark?
Streaming access changes frequently. Use current review evidence as a starting point, then test both VPNs against the same services and regions. The better streaming VPN is the one that works reliably in your current tests without excessive server switching or buffering.
Which is better for torrenting, Private Internet Access or Surfshark?
For torrenting, compare P2P permission, port forwarding, kill-switch behavior, leak protection, and sustained transfer performance. The fastest VPN is not automatically the best P2P choice if it lacks a feature you need. Follow local laws and content rights.
Can I try Private Internet Access and Surfshark before deciding?
Both providers currently advertise refund or guarantee terms in their full reviews: Private Internet Access: 30 days for new subscribers under current terms; Surfshark: 30 days for eligible first purchases. Eligibility and payment-method exclusions can apply, so read the current refund conditions before purchasing.
How to Use This Comparison
This decision page is not a substitute for the two full VPN reviews. The automatic comparison table shown above the article is generated from the linked master VPN Review records. That keeps frequently changing facts such as price, server counts, country coverage, connection limits, refund periods, logging summaries, and affiliate URLs centralized.
If a provider changes a plan, feature, or affiliate destination, update the VPN Review record first. Every linked comparison then uses the refreshed master facts. Update the comparison narrative only when the conclusion, testing evidence, or practical recommendation changes. This reduces duplicate maintenance and lowers the risk of stale pricing or conflicting specs across the site.