Disclosure: OnlyVPNGuide.com may earn a commission if you purchase through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our editorial conclusions.
Quick Answer
Surfshark is the stronger overall choice for most users because it combines unlimited devices, a larger feature set, and stronger mainstream value, while PrivateVPN remains attractive for buyers who want a simple low-cost VPN. Both VPNs can make sense for different users, so the decision should be based on your actual priorities rather than the brand name alone. PrivateVPN is currently positioned around affordable streaming, beginners, simple apps, and users who want low long-term pricing, while Surfshark is positioned around budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value. This comparison weighs each provider’s published features, real-world trade-offs and currently available plan information.
Compare at a glance
Plan details below come from the linked VPN reviews. Missing or unverified fields are labelled; no speed benchmark is implied.
| Feature | PrivateVPN | Surfshark |
|---|---|---|
| Price / plan | $2.00/month on the current 36-month plan | $2.49/month for the current Starter 24-month offer with extra months |
| Server information | About 200 servers | 4,500+ |
| Countries / locations | 62 | 100 |
| Simultaneous connections | 10 | Unlimited |
| Logging policy | Claims a no-logs policy; current independent review notes no third-party audit or real-world verification | Audited no-logs policy; Surfshark says it does not track or store browsing activity |
| Jurisdiction | Sweden | Netherlands |
| Refund terms | 30 days | 30 days for eligible first purchases |
| Best suited to | Affordable streaming, beginners, simple apps, and users who want low long-term pricing | Budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value |
| Full review | Read PrivateVPN review | Read Surfshark review |
Prices, locations and refund rules can change. Confirm the full payment, renewal and eligibility terms on the provider’s website before purchasing.
Key Takeaways
- Overall winner: Surfshark.
- PrivateVPN best fit: Affordable streaming, beginners, simple apps, and users who want low long-term pricing.
- Surfshark best fit: Budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value.
- Current price reference — PrivateVPN: $2.00/month on the current 36-month plan.
- Current price reference — Surfshark: $2.49/month for the current Starter 24-month offer with extra months.
- Connections — PrivateVPN: 10; Surfshark: Unlimited.
- Use the full reviews for extra details about each provider.
Key Differences
The main difference between PrivateVPN and Surfshark is the kind of buyer each service serves best. PrivateVPN’s current review emphasizes affordable streaming, beginners, simple apps, and users who want low long-term pricing, while Surfshark’s review emphasizes budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value. That difference often matters more than one server total or marketing claim.
Compare the current plan details alongside the practical differences described below. That includes price, server count, country coverage, simultaneous connections, logging summary, jurisdiction, refund period, best-for label, and affiliate destination.
Speed Comparison
OnlyVPNGuide has not assigned a new controlled head-to-head speed winner in this review. The PrivateVPN review currently stores the speed field as ‘Not independently measured by OnlyVPNGuide’, while Surfshark stores ‘Not independently measured by OnlyVPNGuide’.
A fair speed comparison should use the same device, ISP, baseline connection, protocol class, time window, and server regions. Test at least one nearby server and two long-distance locations, then record download speed, upload speed, latency, connection time, and stability. Run several passes rather than publishing one best result. Server distance, congestion, Wi-Fi quality, routing, obfuscation, multi-hop, and device performance can all change the outcome.
Privacy & Security
PrivateVPN’s current logging summary is: Claims a no-logs policy; current independent review notes no third-party audit or real-world verification. Its listed jurisdiction is Sweden. Surfshark’s current logging summary is: Audited no-logs policy; Surfshark says it does not track or store browsing activity. Its listed jurisdiction is Netherlands.
Jurisdiction is relevant, but it should never be the only privacy criterion. Compare what browsing and connection data each provider stores, what account/payment information it keeps, whether no-logs claims have been independently audited or tested in the real world, and whether the company publishes transparency information. Also compare protocols, leak protection, kill-switch behavior, ownership, app update practices, and any significant past security or logging events.
Streaming Comparison
Streaming access changes constantly because Netflix, Disney+, Prime Video, BBC iPlayer, and other platforms update VPN detection. The full reviews provide current context, but this page should not promise that a specific service will always work.
Torrenting / P2P
For torrenting and other P2P use, compare whether P2P is permitted, which servers support it, whether port forwarding is available, kill-switch behavior during a forced disconnect, and DNS/IP leak protection under load. The current PrivateVPN review notes: P2P is permitted and PrivateVPN has traditionally been a capable torrenting option, though the small server network can affect congestion and consistency. For a proper P2P test, confirm whether every server allows P2P, whether port forwarding exists, whether the kill switch blocks traffic during a forced disconnect and whether the VPN leaks your real IP under load. Measure sustained file-transfer performance rather than a single burst speed. A VPN can improve privacy around lawful P2P use, but it does not make unlawful downloading lawful, so readers should follow local laws and content rights. The current Surfshark review notes: P2P traffic is supported and the service provides fast modern protocols, but it does not offer port forwarding. Users who need inbound port mapping for P2P workflows may prefer PIA, Proton VPN, or hide.me. A reliable P2P review should check more than whether BitTorrent launches. Confirm which servers permit P2P, whether the provider offers port forwarding, whether the kill switch remains active during a forced disconnect, and whether DNS/IP leaks appear while the client is under load. We have not performed that full workflow for this review, so any measured P2P speed should remain a sourced external reference rather than an OnlyVPNGuide result.
Peak download speed is not the whole story. A provider with reliable port forwarding, stable connections, and a strong no-logs record can be more useful to a serious P2P user than a slightly faster VPN without those features. Conversely, a user who never needs inbound connections may prefer simpler apps or stronger streaming support.
VPN use does not change the legality of files or activity. Readers should follow local law, copyright rules, and service terms.
Apps & Ease of Use
PrivateVPN currently lists 10 simultaneous connections, while Surfshark lists Unlimited. That number matters for households, but app quality should be judged separately on Windows, macOS, Android, iOS, Linux, routers, browsers, and TV devices.
The best app is not necessarily the one with the most switches. A strong design makes the safe default obvious, explains advanced settings, and behaves consistently after sleep, reboot, network changes, and Wi-Fi handoffs.
Server Network
The linked reviews list PrivateVPN with About 200 servers servers and 62 countries/locations. Surfshark is listed with 4,500+ servers and 100 countries/locations. These are dated snapshots and should be verified before purchase.
Raw server count is not a quality score. Providers count physical machines, virtual servers, instances, locations, and cities differently. Network capacity, routing, nearby city choice, server ownership, RAM-only infrastructure, and regional coverage often matter more than the headline number.
Pricing & Value
PrivateVPN’s current price reference is $2.00/month on the current 36-month plan; Surfshark’s is $2.49/month for the current Starter 24-month offer with extra months. The refund references are PrivateVPN: 30 days; Surfshark: 30 days for eligible first purchases.
Do not compare only the advertised effective monthly price. Check how much is charged upfront, the first-term length, bonus months, taxes, automatic renewal, renewal price, and whether important features require a more expensive tier. A two- or three-year discount can be excellent value, but it creates more commitment than a monthly or annual plan.
Customer Support
Customer support matters when something fails: streaming stops working, a router setup breaks, a refund is needed, or a restrictive network blocks the default protocol. Compare live chat, email, response time, troubleshooting quality, and how current the help documentation is.
Who Should Choose PrivateVPN
Choose PrivateVPN if your priorities align with Affordable streaming, beginners, simple apps, and users who want low long-term pricing. It is especially worth considering when its current price structure, device policy, privacy position, or specialist features solve a specific problem for you. Read the full PrivateVPN review before purchasing because this comparison summarizes the most important differences rather than repeating every limitation.
Who Should Choose Surfshark
Choose Surfshark if your priorities align more closely with Budget-focused households, unlimited devices, streaming, and feature-rich value. Focus on the differences that materially affect your use: privacy evidence, unlimited devices, port forwarding, streaming, censorship resistance, ease of use, or long-term cost. The full Surfshark review should be the final fact-check source before you buy.
Final Verdict
Surfshark is the stronger overall choice for most users because it combines unlimited devices, a larger feature set, and stronger mainstream value, while PrivateVPN remains attractive for buyers who want a simple low-cost VPN. That is the recommendation for a typical reader, not a universal rule. The correct choice can change if your main goal is strict privacy, P2P, travel in restrictive countries, household device coverage, streaming, gaming, or the lowest possible price.
FAQs
Which is better overall, PrivateVPN or Surfshark?
For most users in this review, Surfshark is the overall winner. Surfshark is the stronger overall choice for most users because it combines unlimited devices, a larger feature set, and stronger mainstream value, while PrivateVPN remains attractive for buyers who want a simple low-cost VPN. The better choice can still change if you need a specialist feature or have a different privacy, device, streaming, or budget priority.
Which is cheaper, PrivateVPN or Surfshark?
The current price references are PrivateVPN: $2.00/month on the current 36-month plan; Surfshark: $2.49/month for the current Starter 24-month offer with extra months. Promotional pricing and renewals change, so compare the live checkout total, term length, and renewal rather than only the headline monthly equivalent.
Which is better for privacy, PrivateVPN or Surfshark?
PrivateVPN currently states: Claims a no-logs policy; current independent review notes no third-party audit or real-world verification. Surfshark currently states: Audited no-logs policy; Surfshark says it does not track or store browsing activity. Compare the latest audit status, account data, protocols, leak protection, ownership, and jurisdiction before declaring a permanent privacy winner.
Which is better for streaming, PrivateVPN or Surfshark?
Streaming access is time-sensitive. Test both VPNs against the same services and regions close to publication. The better streaming VPN is the one that works consistently on your current devices without excessive server switching or buffering.
Which is better for torrenting, PrivateVPN or Surfshark?
Compare P2P permission, port forwarding, kill-switch behavior, leak protection, and sustained transfer performance. The fastest service is not automatically the best torrenting VPN if it lacks a feature you need.
Can I try PrivateVPN and Surfshark before deciding?
The current refund references are PrivateVPN: 30 days; Surfshark: 30 days for eligible first purchases. Eligibility and payment-method exclusions can apply, so read the current provider terms before purchasing.